Although the label decides that an engagement ring should be returned when a wedding is canceled regardless of who broke the engagement, legal system has opinions on this different question
- Determination circumstances possible :.
- where you live.
- How you got the engagement ring.
- Who broke the engagement.
States where Must Be engagement ring returned:
many courts consider an engagement ring as a conditional gift which is given for marriage. If there is no marriage, the engagement ring must be returned.
The courts have also occurred in these states that the reasoning for the no-fault divorces has no fault broken commitments so an engagement ring should always be returned, regardless of who decided to cancel the commitment
- States conditional gift :.
- Iowa
- Florida
- Kansas
- Michigan
- Minnesota
- New Jersey
- NM
- New York
- Pennsylvania
- Wisconsin
states that an engagement ring can be maintained:
in these places, an engagement ring is considered a implicit conditional gift and if the guy breaks the commitment, it will not get the ring.
If it does not break the commitment, it may request its return. Bottom line: If you find yourself, you get to keep the ring in these states
- implicit contingent gift States :.
- California
- Texas
- Washington
states that an engagement ring can always be maintained:
other courts have held the belief that an engagement ring is a unconditional gift and therefore it does not need to be made
- Gift unconditional States :.
- Montana
Family Heirloom Engagement Rings
If you plan to give an engagement ring family heirloom , legal experts recommend having a prenuptial agreement that the lists that will keep the engagement ring in the case of a rupture.
Special Days
If an engagement ring is given on a special day such as a birthday, Valentine's Day, Christmas, etc., many courts will not require that the engagement ring be returned
Imprint :. This text should not be considered legal advice. Please consult a lawyer familiar with the marriage and family law and your personal circumstances for legal advice on the return of an engagement ring.
State laws often change. Please inform us of any oversights or errors.